![]() |
| Prabowo Apologizes for Haze in Malaysia and Singapore, but 'Not Our Fault' Remark Sparks Debate |
Prabowo Apologizes for Haze in Malaysia and Singapore, but 'Not Our Fault' Remark Sparks Debate
Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto has drawn international attention after apologizing to Malaysia and Singapore over the transboundary haze caused by forest and land fires in Indonesia, while simultaneously saying that the situation was "not our fault."
The statement was delivered during the plenary session of the 49th ASEAN Summit in Manila, the Philippines, on November 15, 2026.
Prabowo acknowledged that smoke from Indonesia's wildfires had crossed national borders and affected neighboring countries. However, his choice of words immediately raised questions about whether the apology also represented an acceptance of responsibility for the environmental crisis.
The controversy comes after one of Indonesia's most severe fire seasons in recent years, with widespread wildfires affecting Sumatra and Kalimantan and sending hazardous smoke across Southeast Asia.
While the Indonesian government says it has deployed tens of thousands of personnel and taken action against companies linked to the fires, international observers are increasingly questioning whether enforcement measures and regional cooperation can prevent another haze crisis.
The issue has also become a major topic at the ASEAN Summit, where Singapore called for stronger regional cooperation to share evidence and hold companies responsible for fires that cause cross-border pollution.
Here is what Prabowo actually said, why his remarks have attracted attention, and what the controversy means for Indonesia's relationship with its Southeast Asian neighbors.
What Did Prabowo Say at the 49th ASEAN Summit?
During the plenary session on November 15, Prabowo addressed the environmental impact of Indonesia's forest and land fires on neighboring countries.
He specifically mentioned Malaysia and Singapore, acknowledging that smoke from the fires had traveled across their borders.
In his speech, Prabowo said:
"We had a very big forest fire which took nearly four months for us to control. The haze travelled to Malaysia and to Singapore. It is not our fault, but once again, we apologize, but we have done our best."
He subsequently apologized again on behalf of the Indonesian government and people for the suffering experienced by residents in the two neighboring countries.
The statement became controversial because the expression "It is not our fault" appeared immediately after his acknowledgment of the cross-border impact.
For some observers, the wording sounded like an apology accompanied by a rejection of responsibility.
However, the statement did not clearly specify whether Prabowo was referring to the occurrence of the fires, the unusually severe weather conditions, or the scale of the resulting haze.
That ambiguity became an important part of the subsequent discussion.
According to the official presidential transcript, Prabowo also emphasized that Indonesia had made significant efforts to control the fires and intended to move from reactive firefighting toward systematic prevention.
Why Did Prabowo Apologize to Malaysia and Singapore?
The apology was connected to the transboundary haze crisis, a recurring environmental problem in Southeast Asia.
Indonesia has experienced major forest and land fires for decades, particularly during prolonged dry seasons.
When fires burn across large areas of Sumatra and Kalimantan, smoke can travel across national borders depending on wind patterns and atmospheric conditions.
This can significantly affect air quality in neighboring countries.
Malaysia and Singapore have repeatedly experienced haze pollution associated with Indonesian fires, making the issue an important part of regional diplomacy.
The 1997–1998 and 2015 fire seasons were among the most serious examples of how domestic land and forest fires can become international environmental crises.
In 2026, the situation returned with renewed intensity.
The fires continued for months, affecting communities across Indonesia and sending smoke toward Malaysia, Singapore, and other parts of Southeast Asia.
Prabowo's apology therefore addressed an environmental problem that has remained unresolved despite years of regional cooperation.
Indonesia Reports 2.88 Million Hectares Burned in 2026
The scale of the 2026 fire season has become one of the main reasons the issue attracted international attention.
According to Nusantara Atlas, a deforestation and land monitoring initiative that analyzes satellite imagery, approximately 2.88 million hectares of land in Indonesia had been affected by fires between January and October 2026.
The estimate was reported by Reuters and other international media.
The figure increased by nearly one million hectares compared with the monitoring organization's previous September update.
The affected areas were concentrated mainly in Sumatra, Kalimantan, and other parts of Indonesia.
The government had previously announced that approximately 202,000 hectares had burned by the end of July. However, it had not released a comparable consolidated official figure for the full period covered by the independent satellite monitoring estimate.
The 2.88 million-hectare figure should therefore be understood as an independent satellite-based estimate, not a final official government total.
The scale of the fires highlights why the haze crisis has become more than a diplomatic issue.
It is also a major environmental, public health, and land management challenge.
Prabowo Says Indonesia Has Deployed 71,000 Firefighters
During his ASEAN speech, Prabowo described the extensive resources deployed to control the fires.
According to the president, Indonesia mobilized approximately 71,000 forest firefighters.
He also reported that:
- 16 personnel died during firefighting operations.
- Many more personnel were injured.
- Two helicopters were lost during the operations.
- The fires had taken nearly four months to bring under control.
Prabowo used these figures to demonstrate the scale of the government's response.
He also said Indonesia was preparing new institutions and programs to strengthen prevention rather than relying primarily on firefighting after blazes had already started.
This shift is important because Indonesia's recurring fire problem cannot be solved through emergency response alone.
Long-term prevention requires better land management, peatland protection, stronger monitoring, and effective enforcement against illegal burning.
For readers interested in the people working on forest protection and fire prevention, see our related coverage:
CPNS 2026 Priority Positions: Forestry Police, Manggala Agni, and Other Government Recruitment Needs
104 Companies Under Investigation: Is Indonesia Taking Action Against Corporate Land Fires?
Another important part of Prabowo's speech concerned companies allegedly connected to forest and land fires.
The president said his administration had taken several enforcement measures against corporations.
According to his statement:
| Enforcement measure | Number reported |
|---|---|
| Corporate concessions revoked | 17 |
| Companies under investigation | 26 |
| Companies already indicted | 11 |
| Companies listed for possible indictment | 23 |
| Total companies under police investigation | 104 |
These figures were presented by Prabowo during the ASEAN Summit.
They describe different enforcement statuses and should not be added together as if they represent separate groups of companies.
The figures also raise an important question: how will the government demonstrate that these measures result in actual accountability?
Revoking a concession does not necessarily establish criminal responsibility.
Similarly, opening an investigation does not mean a company has been proven guilty.
For international observers, the effectiveness of Indonesia's response will depend on transparent investigations, credible evidence, and legal proceedings that lead to enforceable consequences where violations are established.
The government will also need to ensure that companies cannot simply continue similar activities through different subsidiaries or newly established business arrangements.
Why Is "It Is Not Our Fault" Becoming the Most Controversial Part?
The controversy is largely about the difference between expressing regret and accepting responsibility.
Prabowo acknowledged that the haze from Indonesian fires had affected neighboring countries.
However, his statement that it was not Indonesia's fault created ambiguity about the government's position.
There are several possible interpretations.
1. The Government May Be Referring to Extreme Weather Conditions
Prabowo linked the severity of the fires to an exceptionally strong El Niño event.
El Niño can reduce rainfall across parts of Indonesia, creating dry conditions that increase the risk of vegetation and peatland fires.
From this perspective, the president may have been emphasizing that the government did not control the extreme climatic conditions that contributed to the crisis.
However, weather conditions are only one part of the problem.
2. Land Management and Human Activities Remain Important Factors
Forest fires are not explained by climate conditions alone.
Human activities, land conversion, drainage of peatlands, and the use of fire to clear vegetation can increase the likelihood and severity of large-scale fires.
This means that even during extreme El Niño conditions, effective land management and prevention measures remain essential.
3. The Apology Does Not Automatically Resolve the Responsibility Debate
Even if extreme weather contributed to the severity of the fires, Indonesia still has responsibility for preventing, controlling, and investigating fires within its territory.
The distinction is important.
A government may not be responsible for causing a drought, but it remains responsible for implementing policies that reduce fire risks and protect communities from foreseeable environmental damage.
This is why the wording of Prabowo's statement attracted attention beyond its diplomatic context.
What Does the Science Say About El Niño and Climate Change?
A scientific assessment published by World Weather Attribution on November 12, 2026, provides important context for understanding the fires.
The research examined the role of El Niño and human-induced climate change in the severe fire weather experienced across Indonesia between August and October 2026.
Its findings suggest that the crisis cannot be explained by El Niño alone.
According to the researchers:
El Niño was the main driver of exceptionally low rainfall.
The strong El Niño conditions contributed to a prolonged dry period across parts of Indonesia.
Human-induced climate change increased seasonal temperatures.
The study found that climate change increased the intensity of seasonal temperatures by approximately 1.6°C.
Hot and dry conditions became more likely.
The researchers estimated that human-induced warming made the observed extreme fire-weather conditions approximately three times more likely.
Land degradation increased the risk of fires.
Deforestation, peatland drainage, and changes in land use made landscapes more vulnerable to burning during prolonged dry periods.
The study also estimated that approximately 1.9 million hectares had burned by September 2026, using its own assessment period and methodology.
This figure is not directly interchangeable with the 2.88 million-hectare estimate from Nusantara Atlas, which covered January through October.
The scientific findings are significant because they demonstrate that climate change and El Niño can intensify fire conditions, while human activities and land management determine how vulnerable landscapes become.
The researchers also emphasized that the increasing predictability of extreme fire weather creates opportunities for governments to strengthen prevention measures.
Their recommendations include peatland restoration, maintaining higher water tables, protecting remaining forests, and reducing reliance on burning for land clearing.
How Did Singapore Respond to Prabowo's Apology?
One of the most important developments at the ASEAN Summit came from Singapore Prime Minister Lawrence Wong.
Rather than focusing exclusively on the wording of Prabowo's apology, Wong called for stronger regional cooperation to identify and hold companies responsible for fires that cause transboundary haze.
Singapore and Indonesia had previously agreed to establish a joint task force to investigate companies linked to forest and land fires.
Wong proposed expanding this arrangement into an ASEAN-wide platform.
The proposed regional mechanism would allow countries to:
- Share information about companies linked to forest fires.
- Exchange evidence across national jurisdictions.
- Improve cooperation between law enforcement agencies.
- Hold companies accountable when violations are established.
- Strengthen prevention rather than responding only after fires occur.
Wong also acknowledged the efforts made by Indonesian firefighters and emergency personnel.
He thanked Prabowo for the government's efforts to investigate the fires and pursue companies that may have violated environmental rules.
This response is important because it shows that Singapore's position was not simply a rejection of Indonesia's apology.
Instead, Singapore emphasized that the next step should involve stronger regional enforcement.
The proposal also reflects Singapore's interest in ensuring that companies operating across national borders cannot avoid accountability simply because their business activities involve several jurisdictions.
Did Malaysia Reject Prabowo's Apology?
There is an important distinction between criticism of Prabowo's wording and the official diplomatic response from Malaysia.
Malaysia was one of the countries directly affected by the haze and was specifically mentioned in the president's apology.
However, available reporting does not establish that the Malaysian government formally rejected the apology or issued an official condemnation of the statement that the fires were not Indonesia's fault.
Malaysia's Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim also raised the haze issue during the ASEAN Summit.
According to reporting by CNA, Malaysia proposed two initiatives:
Science Diplomacy
This initiative would strengthen scientific cooperation and evidence-based decision-making in addressing transboundary haze.
Sustainable Haze Fund
The proposed fund would provide a more sustainable financial mechanism to support implementation of the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.
Malaysia intends to continue pushing these priorities through regional ministerial cooperation.
These proposals suggest that Malaysia is focusing on long-term regional solutions rather than relying solely on diplomatic statements.
Online Reactions: Was Prabowo Apologizing Without Accepting Responsibility?
Prabowo's statement also attracted attention on social media, particularly in Singapore.
Singaporean media outlet Plan B reported that some netizens questioned the sincerity of the apology after hearing the phrase "It is not our fault."
The online discussion reflected several different perspectives.
Some users viewed the statement as an apology that avoided accepting responsibility.
Others argued that an apology would have little meaning unless followed by concrete action against companies responsible for fires.
Some also pointed out that Indonesian communities had suffered from the fires and smoke and deserved recognition of their own experiences.
These reactions demonstrate that the controversy is not limited to diplomatic relations between governments.
It also involves public expectations regarding environmental accountability.
However, the reported comments should not be treated as a representative survey of public opinion in Singapore or Malaysia.
The available evidence shows that the statement generated online criticism, but it does not establish that the majority of citizens in either country rejected Prabowo's apology.
Why Is the Haze Crisis a Long-Standing Problem for ASEAN?
The transboundary haze issue has been one of Southeast Asia's recurring environmental challenges for decades.
Large-scale fires in Indonesia have repeatedly affected neighboring countries, particularly Malaysia and Singapore.
The crisis became especially severe during the 1997–1998 and 2015 fire seasons.
In response, ASEAN adopted the Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution in 2002.
The agreement was designed to improve regional cooperation in preventing, monitoring, and responding to haze pollution caused by land and forest fires.
However, the existence of a regional agreement has not completely prevented recurring haze episodes.
One challenge is that environmental enforcement is primarily conducted through national legal systems.
Countries may have different standards for investigating companies, collecting evidence, and imposing penalties.
Another challenge is the cross-border nature of corporate operations.
A company involved in land clearing may operate through subsidiaries, business partners, or concession arrangements across several jurisdictions.
This makes information-sharing and legal cooperation particularly important.
At the 49th ASEAN Summit, leaders renewed calls to strengthen the ASEAN Coordinating Centre for Transboundary Haze Pollution Control.
The Philippines' Foreign Affairs Secretary, Ma. Theresa Lazaro, said ASEAN leaders had encouraged member states to prioritize the ratification and operationalization of the regional mechanism.
The aim is to ensure that the regional institution can coordinate information, support cooperation, and strengthen collective responses to future haze emergencies.
What Happens Next After Prabowo's ASEAN Apology?
The controversy will ultimately be judged by the actions that follow the president's statement.
Several developments will determine whether Indonesia and its ASEAN partners can prevent another major haze crisis.
1. Corporate investigations must produce concrete results
The Indonesian government has reported investigations, revoked concessions, and legal action involving companies linked to fires.
The next challenge is ensuring that investigations are transparent and that legal proceedings are supported by credible evidence.
2. Singapore and Indonesia must strengthen joint enforcement
The bilateral task force proposed by both countries could become an important model for regional cooperation.
Its effectiveness will depend on whether authorities can exchange evidence and take action against companies operating across borders.
3. ASEAN needs a stronger regional coordination mechanism
Lawrence Wong's proposal to expand the task force into an ASEAN-wide platform could help address the limitations of purely bilateral cooperation.
4. Indonesia must improve peatland and forest management
Restoring degraded peatlands, preventing illegal land clearing, and protecting remaining forests will be essential to reducing future fire risks.
5. Climate preparedness must become a priority
The World Weather Attribution findings suggest that extreme fire weather is becoming more severe.
Governments therefore need to improve early-warning systems, fire monitoring, emergency preparedness, and public health protection.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Prabowo say at the 49th ASEAN Summit?
Prabowo apologized to Malaysia and Singapore for the haze caused by Indonesian forest fires but also said, "It is not our fault." The statement generated debate about whether Indonesia was accepting responsibility for the cross-border environmental impact.
Why did Prabowo apologize to Malaysia and Singapore?
The president acknowledged that smoke from Indonesian forest and land fires had crossed national borders and affected communities in both countries.
Did Malaysia and Singapore reject Prabowo's apology?
There is no confirmed official rejection of the apology. Singapore Prime Minister Lawrence Wong acknowledged Indonesia's efforts and proposed stronger ASEAN-wide cooperation to investigate companies linked to fires.
How many hectares were burned in Indonesia in 2026?
Nusantara Atlas estimated that approximately 2.88 million hectares had been affected by fires between January and October 2026. This is an independent satellite-based estimate rather than a final official government figure.
Was El Niño responsible for Indonesia's 2026 forest fires?
El Niño contributed to unusually low rainfall and dry conditions, but scientific research also identified human-induced climate change, deforestation, peatland drainage, and land-use changes as important factors.
How many companies are being investigated over Indonesia's forest fires?
Prabowo said that 104 companies were under police investigation overall. He also reported 17 revoked corporate concessions, 11 companies already indicted, and 23 listed for possible indictment. These are different enforcement categories and should not be added together.
What is ASEAN doing to prevent future haze crises?
ASEAN is working to strengthen its regional coordination mechanism for transboundary haze pollution. Singapore has also proposed expanding its joint task force with Indonesia into an ASEAN-wide platform for sharing evidence and holding companies accountable.
Sources and Further Reading
- Reuters – Indonesia President Conveys Apology to Singapore, Malaysia Over Wildfire Haze
- Channel NewsAsia – Indonesia President Prabowo Apologises to Singapore, Malaysia Over Transboundary Haze
- Channel NewsAsia – Singapore-Indonesia Haze Task Force Should Become ASEAN-Wide Platform: PM Wong
- Financial Times – Indonesia Apologises to Neighbours for Toxic Haze
- World Weather Attribution – Climate Change Is Increasing the Severity of El Niño-Driven Fire Weather Across Indonesia
- Reuters – Climate Change Made Indonesian Fires More Severe, Scientists Say
- The Jakarta Post – Indonesia Forest Fires Burned Through Nearly 2.9 Million Hectares
- Philippine News Agency – ASEAN Foreign Ministers Push to Operationalize Transboundary Haze Control Hub
- Plan B Singapore – Netizens Question Prabowo's Haze Apology After He Says "It Is Not Our Fault"
- Official Presidential Transcript – Prabowo's Remarks at the 49th ASEAN Summit
Related Teman Karir Coverage:
